Hello Reader,

When a community is trying to address a public health problem, the immediate causes are often the most apparent.

Too many youth aren't physically active. Why? They don't understand the value of physical activity or the consequences of not being active. What should we do? An education and mass communication campaign to help them understand this value and these consequences, so that they are motivated to be more active.

Not only are immediate causes often the most apparent, the solutions required to address them are often (relatively) non-controversial and don't require the upheaval of established systems.

But to truly transform health in communities, we need to move beyond the immediate. We need to 1) drill down to root causes and 2) fly up for a systems wide view.

On the first point -

WHY are too many youth not physically active? Do they have safe spaces to run and play in their neighborhood, and do their schedules allow them to do so? Are the costs of joining recreational sports leagues prohibitive? Are the apps on their phones designed to be addictive, so they have less time for everything else?

To get community members thinking about root causes, one exercise I have found quite helpful is a fishbone diagram (where you start with the problem, which is the "head" of the fish, and then brainstorm multiple causes, as well as causes of causes). This diagramming is often paired with the "5 whys" facilitation strategy (where you keep asking "why" five times to drill down to deeper root causes). The idea here is that this process can help identify countermeasures (things that prevent root causes) instead of merely solutions (things that might just put a bandaid on the problem by treating a symptom instead of a root cause).

On the second point -

HOW might systems be transformed to encourage more physical activity among youth?

First, we need to be able to take a step back and see the system as a whole. I find the elephant analogy an incredibly helpful way to remind ourselves and our communities to do this. It’s an ancient parable you may have heard before about blind/blindfolded individuals encountering an elephant for the first time. Each person feels only one part of the elephant and comes to a conclusion about what they are encountering based on that. It leads to a lot of misconceptions and no single person who has the full and accurate picture.

To take community thinking a step further, from recognizing there is a broader system to understanding how we can improve that system, I love using the iceberg model of systems thinking. It's a great way to reminder ourselves that what we can see of a problem is usually only the tip of the iceberg. "We know that an iceberg has only 10 percent of its total mass above the water while 90 percent is underwater. But that 90 percent is what the ocean currents act on, and what creates the iceberg’s behavior at its tip." Most public health issues are like this as well! I especially appreciate the way this model helps community members walk through the process of identifying trends, underlying structures, and ultimately mental models.

I've often had clients point to a fairly surface-level approach or solution and say, "This is what our community said they want to see." This may be true, and I'm 100% on board with community-driven approaches. However, we also need to ask ourselves if we've walked ourselves and our communities through the kind of tools above to make sure that the solutions we're brainstorming are oriented towards root causes and systems.

Have you had success with setting the stage to approach problems in a way that is focused on root causes or systems? Or have you tried using any of the tools mentioned above? Please share your experience with me!
​
Until next time,

Vinu

PS Learn something in this newsletter? Spread the word! Forward this email to a friend or colleague who might want to weave their own community threads.

PPS Want to learn more about PoP Health and how we partner with community coalitions and collaboratives to transform health in communities through policy and systems change? Check out our website!

Copyright © 2023 PoP Health, All rights reserved.

You’re receiving this email because you signed up for the Community Threads newsletter. We’re delighted to have you be a part of our community. There’s nothing we respect more than community, so rest assured, your contact information is safe with us. If you’re no longer interested in learning how to work with communities to transform health, Unsubscribe or Change Your Preferences​

If you need our mailing address, you can reach us at 3056 Hickory Grove Ct, Fairfax, VA 22031.
​